When legislation helps critical infrastructure work together

New research suggests that legislation can do more than set rules; it can help organisations share knowledge and protect the systems communities rely on

Climate change is placing critical infrastructure under growing pressure, with consequences extending beyond the assets directly damaged, according to the World Economic Forum’s Global Risks Report 2026. The services communities rely on – energy, water and transport – are closely connected, so a disruption to one can quickly affect others.

Preparing for those disruptions is therefore not the responsibility of any single organisation. Instead, it depends on government agencies and infrastructure operators understanding how their systems are interdependent and coordinating when problems arise.

Legislation is often associated with rules and compliance. However, a recent study of Victoria’s infrastructure resilience framework indicates that it can also shape how organisations work together – by requiring preparation, creating opportunities to share information and stimulating a broader sense of responsibility for the system.

The research, The Many Lives of Law in the Commons: How Legislation Shapes Collaborative Engagement, published in Business & Society, was co-authored by Dr Marloes Korendijk, Dr Nader Naderpajouh and Dr Bart De Keyser from the University of Sydney, and Dr Christiaan Röell, a Scientia lecturer in the School of Management and Governance at UNSW Business School.

Dr Christiaan Röell, School of Management and Governance, UNSW Business School.jpg
UNSW Business School Scientia lecturer Christiaan Röell explains how legislation can build the shared responsibility needed to keep interdependent essential services running through climate disruptions. Photo: UNSW Sydney

“Climate change makes preparing our essential services for disruption an increasingly urgent collective challenge,” Dr Röell said. “Electricity, water and transport depend on one another, yet responsibility for them is spread across organisations with different priorities and resources,” he added. “We wanted to understand how legislation could support the relationships and shared responsibility needed to keep essential services functioning through disruption.”

The researchers examine what they call “infrastructure commons”: shared systems whose value depends not just on physical assets, but also on how different organisations use, connect and govern them. Their case study examines Victoria’s critical infrastructure resilience framework, which combines legal requirements with policy guidance and opportunities for collaboration across eight critical infrastructure sectors. The study focuses on water, energy and transport.

The study draws on interviews with 26 people from 12 government bodies and infrastructure organisations, as well as analysis of legislation, government reports, and other documents. It identifies three overlapping ways in which the framework can shape engagement: compliance, reciprocity, and stewardship.

When the law sets the minimum

The first pathway is compliance, with the legislation requiring organisations to take certain steps, such as preparing risk management plans, conducting exercises, submitting statements of assurance and undergoing audits. These obligations give organisations a reason to prepare and clarify their responsibilities.

But meeting these requirements does not necessarily lead to closer cooperation. Some interviewees described their engagement as focused merely on doing what the law required, with collaboration limited to formal exercises or reporting. The researchers found that organisations could meet their legislative obligations while remaining focused mainly on their own operations.

Learn more: How infrastructure delays threaten Western Sydney housing supply

“Interviewees told us that legal requirements helped them secure resources and get preparedness taken seriously within their organisations,” Dr Korendijk said. “But they also described that engagement generally only concerned completing the required exercises and reports. The concern is that organisations can satisfy those requirements without adequately collaborating with others.”

Creating space to share and learn

The framework also established sector resilience networks and cross-sector forums, bringing infrastructure operators and government representatives together to discuss risks and interdependencies. At one annual forum, participants explored what a major energy disruption could mean for other sectors, helping them see how an outage might affect organisations beyond energy providers.

The networks also brought together operators who might not otherwise meet. Transport organisations, rail and airport operators, for example, could compare their exercises and discuss what might happen if a resource on which their operations depend were to stop working. That gave participants a better sense of whom to contact and what risks others were managing.

"Climate change makes preparing our essential services for disruption an increasingly urgent collective challenge"

CHRISTIAAN ROELL

The researchers found that over time, some organisations came to treat these meetings as a chance to exchange practical lessons, rather than simply another obligation. Participants described sharing approaches with smaller or less experienced organisations, while also learning from others.

The framework combined mandatory requirements for infrastructure classified as vital with opportunities for wider participation, creating settings in which relationships could develop.

“These networks allowed operators to hear about concerns and preparedness practices they might otherwise know little about. That matters because a plan developed within one organisation can rest on assumptions about another,” Dr Röell said. “Bringing those perspectives together gives operators an opportunity to examine those assumptions before they are tested by a disruption.”

Taking responsibility for the wider system

A third pathway emerged when organisations saw their own operations as part of a connected system. A transport operator, for example, depends on reliable electricity and water to keep tunnels operating; if either service fails, the consequences extend far beyond the organisation that owns or operates them.

In these cases, some organisations went beyond the requirements and exchanged expertise to help others build resilience. The researchers describe this as stewardship: supporting the health of the wider infrastructure system, even where the organisation may not receive an immediate or direct return.

Subscribe to BusinessThink for the latest research, analysis and insights from UNSW Business School

“One organisation described helping another organisation prepare its statement of assurance,” Dr Korendijk said. “That is stewardship in practice, with an experienced operator sharing its expertise to help another organisation. There may be no immediate benefit for that focal organisation, yet strengthening another provider can support the wider system on which both organisations depend."

Why organisations respond differently

The three pathways were not mutually exclusive, and organisations didn’t respond to the framework in the same way, the researchers found. Engagement varied with factors including sector maturity, competition, ownership and accountability, and the time and resources available to each organisation. In some settings, the existence of established relationships meant legislation added little; in others, limited capacity or competitive pressures made deeper collaboration harder.

The research shows that requirements can set a baseline for preparation, but meaningful collaboration also depends on the structures and resources that let organisations learn from each other and understand their mutual risks. Forums, guidance and feedback on reporting can help turn compliance activities into routines for cooperation.

Forums and guidance are essential to turn baseline legal compliance into genuine cooperation.jpeg
Because organisations differ in capacity and market pressures, forums and guidance are essential to turn baseline legal compliance into genuine cooperation. Photo: Adobe Stock

“The same requirement can help one organisation establish a useful routine and leave another repeating work it already does under a different obligation,” Dr Röell explained. “Policymakers should examine those differences before adding requirements. Our findings suggest pairing clear minimum expectations with practical guidance and opportunities to learn, while checking whether the demands on staff leave them enough time to participate meaningfully.”

The research suggests that infrastructure operators preparing for disruption should look beyond their own plans. By understanding dependencies, building relationships with other operators and sharing experience, organisations can better prepare for disruptions that cross sector boundaries. 

“We hope that our research encourages operators and government to examine the assumptions of dependency and collaboration together, while there is still time to adjust plans before hazards occur,” Dr Korendijk said.

Five recommendations for policymakers and infrastructure leaders

  1. Policymakers should pair minimum preparedness requirements with forums, guidance and joint risk assessments that help organisations share information and lessons.
  2. Infrastructure leaders should use those forums to understand how their operations depend on other organisations and sectors.
  3. Organisations should build relationships with other operators before a disruption, so they know who to contact and what risks they share.
  4. More experienced operators should share expertise and good practice with organisations that have fewer resources or less established resilience processes.
  5. Policymakers should account for differences in organisational resources, sector maturity and competitive pressures when designing frameworks for collaboration.

Republish

You are free to republish this article both online and in print. We ask that you follow some simple guidelines.

Please do not edit the piece, ensure that you attribute the author, their institute, and mention that the article was originally published on Business Think.

By copying the HTML below, you will be adhering to all our guidelines.

Press Ctrl-C to copy