High-speed rail can generate economic growth to help pay for itself
Land value growth could be used to fund the proposed high-speed rail network on the east coast of Australia, UNSW research shows
Land values and property prices around high-speed rail stations would increase by potentially up to $140 billion – a significant portion of which could be dedicated to funding its construction.
High-Speed Rail Value Uplift: Preliminary Investigation Report, released this week from the UNSW City Futures Research Centre, calculates estimated growth – or ‘value uplift’ – in land values due to the high-speed rail. It suggests adopting policies that funnel economic growth from the high-speed rail towards offsetting its costs would see taxpayers share the benefits of land value increases while reducing the pressure on governments to finance it.
According to report estimates, the land surrounding a number of stations along the proposed high-speed rail line on the east coast would experience a significant value increase – between $48 billion to $140 billion, in the population growth scenarios used in the report. The projections on both infrastructure-related uplift for existing residential properties from improved accessibility and planning-related value uplift from land rezoned to residential use around the stations.
Professor Christopher Pettit, Director of UNSW City Futures Research Centre, conducted the research alongside postgraduate researchers Will Thackway and Reg Wade through the Value Australia project, which has received funding support through the federal government’s Cooperative Research Centre Project (CRC-P) program. The project uses the power of data analytics and artificial intelligence to provide insights into Australia’s property market.
“We’ve put together this report for policymakers and decision-makers to explore these growth scenarios and make informed decisions based on big data and analytics,” Prof. Pettit says. “There are a lot of opportunities around high-speed rail for Australia to build stronger connectivity between cities and inject significant wealth and job opportunities into the regions. The numbers in the report confirm and help quantify that considerable potential.”
Capturing value uplift
The researchers calculated value uplift from improved accessibility by applying a value uplift coefficient, based on international case studies, on the total value of existing residential dwellings within the catchment area of proposed regional high-speed rail stops. The value uplift from planning control changes was calculated by subtracting the development costs from each area’s expected new dwelling values to obtain the residual land value per new dwelling. The projected residual land value for each area was then multiplied by a range of population growth scenarios to get the final figures.
“We expect the values to be a conservative approach to estimation and that the total value uplift could actually be higher,” Prof. Pettit says. “This is while still factoring in a profit for the developers after all the external costs, including stamp duty, legal fees and building costs.”
The report says the value uplift, as a direct result of high-speed rail and population growth in surrounding areas, can be captured with various policies known as ‘value capture.’ While the concept isn’t new – it partially funded the Sydney Harbour Bridge’s construction – it has been used to fund many major rail projects abroad. Recently, the Crossrail project in the UK, the Greater London Authority implemented a Business Rate Supplement, which is expected to generate £4.1 billion ($7.7 billion), contributing substantially to the total cost of the whole project of £14.8 billion ($27.9 billion).
Read more: Sydney to Newcastle fast rail makes sense. Making trains locally does not
Betterment levies, developer charges or taxes on property transactions are among the various mechanisms available to secure some of the benefits delivered by public investment. For high-speed rail in Australia, just how much value uplift can be captured comes down to the value capture policy frameworks and structure put in place.
“If you were to capture a substantial proportion of this value uplift, it could pay for a huge amount of high-speed rail,” Prof. Pettit says. “You would be looking at tens of billions of dollars just from the residential value uplift alone, without even factoring in commercial, industrial and other beneficiaries.”
“Some of that value capture could also be used to invest into housing affordability schemes. It doesn’t necessarily all need to go towards the infrastructure,” Prof. Pettit says. “It’s about ensuring that growth and benefits can be fairly and equitably distributed with maximum value.”
A nation-building project
Business leaders committed to infrastructure progress have also endorsed the creation of high-speed rail to have an outsized economic and social impact on regional cities.
“A nation-building infrastructure project like this will go a long way to alleviating supply issues while supporting regional economic development and improved connectivity,” says James Abbott, Managing Director of Abbott Advisory, advisor to leading Australian property and infrastructure groups.
“High-speed Rail can breathe new life into East Coast Australian cities and regions, driving prosperity and social equity for decades to come. It would be a gift from us to our future generations. And this study indicates the potential for achieving it. It’s time to get on with high-speed rail,” says Prof. Andrew McNaughton, Chairman at Network Rail (High Speed) Limited.
The report also recommends that further research be conducted into the use of value uplift financial instruments, the formulation of a national settlement plan, and creating a national cities institute to ensure the maximum benefits realisation of a high-speed rail network across Australia.
Such initiatives would assist the nation in significantly reducing emissions in the long term and go a long way to ensuring liveable, sustainable, productive, and resilient cities are planned along the high-speed rail, Prof. Pettit says.
“Australia is in an excellent position to capitalise on this infrastructure that would be transformational for the nation,” Prof. Pettit says. “If Government were to make a significant investment into high-speed rail, it would show strong leadership and vision and set up future generations of Australia into 2060 and beyond.”